Thursday, January 8, 2009

January 6 Council Meeting

In the first council meeting of the new year it didn't take long for the line in the sand to be drawn. The first order of business after the opening ceremonies was the election of Council Pro-tem. Joe Soldano was nominated by Don Brown and only garnered three votes in his favor with three in opposition. Refusing to break the tie the mayor opened the floor to any additional nominations and Tony Cataldo nominated John McMahon. McMahon got three yea votes and three nay. At this point the mayor got a rare opportunity to vote and stated it was nothing against Soldano. He stated he thought Joe did a great job as Pro-Tem in '08 but felt if someone else was interested they should get chance to serve in that position. He then gave his vote to McMahon.

Council Pro-Tem is a power position. Not only do they fill in for the mayor in any absence but they also appoint other council members to the various committee chairs along with the other members to the committees. It's a form of lining up your team for the year.

Soldano was noticeably upset about losing Pro-tem. The next order of business was the appointment of Council Committees and McMahon advised he was not prepared for that. After saying that Soldano accused McMahon of having his selections ready last week. He wasn't smiling when he made that accusation. Later on after the meeting Soldano was quoted as saying he was suspicious that the vote was a set up job. He was quoted in the ER as saying "this was not done right, believe me". He was quoted in the MJ as saying "he believed the decision was made to elect McMahon in the position before the 2008 year ended. People setting things up behind your back. It makes you mad." According to what Soldano told reporters the pro-tem position is talked about in the Council Caucus office before the first meeting of the new year but never before the new year begins. I guess Joe was talking about informal discussions among the council members and not in a meeting type forum. I'm sure he wouldn't violate the provisions of the Sunshine Law with closed door meetings about something that is to be decided by a public body in open chambers. Right Joe?

From what was quoted in the newspapers with his comments to the reporters after the meeting it sounds to me that is what Joe is accusing the mayor and three council members of doing. One former mayor told me it has always been policy with council to let anyone who wants to serve in the position to let the new guy do the job. It may be more of an informal understanding rather than it being set in stone. To me it's pure and simple politics. Instead of getting mad, upset and making accusations it would be nice to see our council members working together with any new arrangement. Animosity as was witnessed or reported does not give us hope that everyone will be trying to work together. The line was drawn but it wasn't necessary to kick up the sand.

Anybody seen Joe Scarabino lately? He hasn't attended any of the last three meetings. Fire Chief Bill Smith gave his statistical report for '08 saying that the WFD responded to 185 incidents with an average response time of 3.5 minutes. Out of those 185 call outs 31 was for fire calls. Nine were for false alarms or calls. The rest was for various categories.

Village Administrator Jim Saracco had nothing to report. Being a rainy evening with temperatures close to freezing I'm guessing he was preoccupied with thoughts of calling out the troops with the salt trucks.

Zoning Administrator Rick Williams reported that the ville took in just $2,896 in permits for '08. There's a very good indication of how much the economy has taken a down turn around here. There's not much remodeling or new construction going on around here.

In the Mayor's Report Joe Surace appointed Justine Monte and Jeff MacLean as new members to the Tree Board Committee. Here I thought they were already members. Both of them did a lot of work when they planted the new trees on Broadway.

The Mayor also reported that they will be advertising for a new Animal Control Officer. Newly selected Patty Boley had to resign because of family commitments. I'm sorry it didn't work out for Patty. You got to give her a hand for trying though. Applications for the position will accepted through January 16 at the Mayor's Office.

The mayor also reported that folks from the Census Bureau will be in town January 13 to give tests to anyone that would like to have a job doing the next census in 2010. They will be in town January 13 and will be conducting two testing sessions. The first will be at 10 A.M. and the second will be at 2 P.M. The jobs pay anywhere from $8/hour to $16 depending on the position. I didn't get an exact location but I'm thinking it will be at Village Hall. Will have to get a clarification on that.

Under new legislation it was voted to renew the lease for office space for Congressman Charlie Wilson's district office. The least runs concurrent with Wilson's term of office. The rent remains at $200/month and runs through December 2010. The vote was under suspension of rules and this time there was no opposition.

In New Business Tony Cataldo made a motion to take the Fiscal Officer's salary from three different funds instead of it all being taken out of the General Fund. The purpose of this move was to lessen the burden on the General Fund. With no one voting against it the salary will now be 40% out of the General Fund and 30% out each the Street Fund and the Sewage Fund.

Cataldo also reported that the Village got a letter from the State Auditor's office stating that we are formally out of fiscal emergency. It took a while but it was good news.

Since there were no Committee appointments there was no Committee reports. No mention was made about the tabled Cataldo Construction bill.

The next meeting should be January 20. It'll be interesting to see McMahon's line up and what new antics this will provoke.

Stay tuned...

ole nib

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

FYI - Justine & Jeff were already tree board members. The mayor actually re-appointed them for 2 years.

Anonymous said...

I was at the meeting, Soldano didn't look upset to me. But I heard that McMahon told Tony Cataldo right before going into Council Chambers that he did not want Pro tem but Cataldo begged him to take it. I know Joe works together with everybody, maybe he is sick of the behind close door crap that goes on. Cataldo needs to stick to his own business, and let other people think for themselves.

Anonymous said...

Soldano was right, McMahon and Tony Cataldo came in Village Hall a week ago giving the committee sheet to have it typed up, with committees made up. Then McMahon came in last Fri. to pick them up. There are plenty of people to back this up. See this is breaking the law, how do you no, you will be elected before the election. Call the Ohio Ethics Commission, ask them. They might tell you that somebody is setting up an election before it takes place. That's why people watch everything Surace does, they know how he and Cataldo operate. No wonder good people up there trying to better Wellsville, get pissed off at these antics.

Anonymous said...

I was told the real reason Patty Boley quit was because Surace promised her a car, old police cruiser to do her job, When she asked him about it he said he didn't remember that, then she quit.

Anonymous said...

Tell the former Mayor that's not true. Council always talked about the position, it was not done this time. The former Mayor is well aware of behind closed door set ups, he had enough of them set up against him.

Anonymous said...

The choice of pro-tempore is solely councils' and the mayor should not have been involved in the process at all. His sole purpose for being at COUNCIL meetings is to oversee the meetings and break any ties. If McMahon truly wanted the position, why did he not talk to Soldano, Goss, or Brown about it? This was underhanded at best. I really don't blame McMahon because he is guided by Cataldo and Surace and really doesn't have a clue what being pro-tempore really means. A good mayor would have just told the council members to work it out and don't appoint pro-tem until four of you can agree. Surace thinks he controls council, or at least he tries, but there are those on council who are tired of the bull and want to do things right. Surace and Cataldo were hell bent on getting McMahon in that position. It will be interesting to see why.

Anonymous said...

WE MUST GET MORE GOOD, HONEST, PEOPLE TO RUN FOR MAYOR, AND COUNCIL. WE HAVE A FEW DOWN THERE, BUT WE NEED MORE. HOW CAN WE MOVE FORWARD WHEN BEHIND CLOSED DOOR ANTICS GO ON. THE LAST ELECTION SHOWED SURACE THAT WELLSVILLE PEOPLE ARE TIRED OF HIS ANTICS, GUESS HE DIDN'T GET THE MESSAGE. I AGREE, CATALDO AND SURACE WANTED MCMAHON PRO TEM FOR A REASON, THEY KNOW THEY CAN'T CONTROL SOLDONO.

Anonymous said...

It is the Mayor's responsiblity and duty to break ties. Do not criticize the Mayor for breaking the tie. It is town knowledge Soldano already had Don and Rosie in his pocket and now he wants to control the Mayor. No one selected committees either. This was not underhanded. Someone needs to quit being a power hungry councilman. Do the job you were elected to do. I don't think whining and complaining all the time are in your job description!

Anonymous said...

Remember the Mayor is alive. Pro temp only takes over in the absence of the Mayor. What is the big issue here?

Anonymous said...

Breaking the tie is what the Mayor did poster #5. Welcome to politics. Wouldn't it be underhanded if the other council members where to talk to Mcmahon before hand? Also, you would be on here bitching about the Mayor had he not broken the tie if it would have been different results. You're the typical whiner on here, that must have it out for the Mayor or a few council members. Grow up and deal with reality.

************* said...

A comment made January 8 said Patty quit the Animal Control job because she didn't get an old cruiser that she was promised. I called Patty to confirm and found out there could be nothing farther from the truth.

According to what I was told she was promised old cruiser #3 and a cage to contain any animals. She was told they had to back down on the promise of her using an old cruiser and was never given a cage. Then out of the blue she got a call from the mayor asking her to resign because they got one complaint. One.

Patty told me she was leery from the beginning because of her family obligations but she had a back up with the St. Francis folks. In her brief tenure she took in five dogs. She confirmed there was only one call she was unable to respond to in spite of the fact that she was getting several late night calls that turned out to be false alarms.

I tend to believe Patty over what we were told. Why folks would stoop so low to discourage her is unknown to me. It wasn't right. Why would they offer a job to anyone and then tie their hands with not supplying the tools to do the job?

Has anyone seen the ad to replace her?

nib

************* said...

Genius - I had to think on it for a few days and decided that NO I'm not going to print your comments.

I don't agree with your line of thinking. If you want to open a forum on your subject you will have to find another venue. Google makes it very easy to set up a blog. I will not be encouraging the use of any illicit drugs.

nib

Anonymous said...

If the mayor's job is to break ties, then why did he not break the first tie when Soldano was nominated? Didn't have the nerve to vote no?

Anonymous said...

Remember the Ohio Board of Ethics is a two way street. Are you exempt from exposure to the Ethics Board. The anonymous who is calling the Ohio Ethics Board, I would think first if I were you.

Anonymous said...

I know all about the Ohio Ethics Board, I used to be a member. I don't have to worry, I know the book of laws.

Anonymous said...

Scarabino has not been to a Council meeting in 2 years. Surace will have to make him go, or you won't see him. The Fire Chief goes to almost every meeting, Scarabino is no better than he is. It would be nice if Scarabino would come and give reports to Council and residents like Smith does. Call around the County Nib, ask how often other towns Police Chiefs attend meetings.

Anonymous said...

Scarabino doesn't attend meetings because he is not allowed to charge overtime for attending.

Anonymous said...

Police chief is to busy fighting crime to go to a meeting.